Microsimulation Report Components
Item Type | Title/Description | Report Context | Purpose/Use | Notes |
---|---|---|---|---|
Section | Executive Summary – concise overview of key objectives, assumptions and findings. | Policy evaluation; Technical documentation; (often public summary uses highlights) | Summarize main results and conclusions for quick reader insight. | Typically included (often page before Introduction). |
Section | Abstract – brief summary of the report’s content. | Technical documentation; (sometimes policy evaluation) | Provide a standalone synopsis of aims, methods, and results. | Common in academic-style or formal reports. |
Section | Acknowledgments – credits to contributors/funders. | Technical documentation; Policy evaluation | Recognize contributors, data sources, funding. | Often included in formal reports. |
Section | Introduction / Background – context, objectives, model overview. | All (Policy evaluation; Technical; Public) | Describe purpose of study, model background, policy context. | Always included; often outlines tax-benefit system and study scope. |
Section | Literature/Policy Context – review of related work or policy motivation. | Policy evaluation; Public summary | Explain why the analysis is needed, cite precedents. | Optional; may appear as part of Introduction or standalone. |
Section | Data and Assumptions – description of input microdata, population, adjustments. | Technical documentation; Policy evaluation | Detail data sources (e.g. surveys, tax records) and any weighting or adjustments. | Common in model country reports and appendices (e.g. SILC data list). |
Section | Model / Methodology – outline of model design, coding of tax-benefit rules. | Technical documentation; Policy evaluation | Describe the microsimulation engine, tax/benefit rules coded, behavioral assumptions. | Included in technical manuals and country reports; may refer to programming or algorithms. |
Section | Policy Scenarios – description of specific reform scenarios or counterfactuals. | Policy evaluation | Define counterfactual policy settings and scenarios tested. | Explicitly described before results (e.g. child benefit or tax changes). |
Section | Results – Fiscal Impact – narrative on aggregate revenue and expenditure changes. | Policy evaluation | Explain overall budgetary effects of reforms (Δtaxes, Δbenefits). | May accompany tables/figures of revenue; often first part of results. |
Section | Results – Distributional Impact – narrative on income, poverty, inequality effects. | Policy evaluation; Public summary | Interpret changes in incomes, poverty rates, inequality measures. | Often broken into sub-sections (e.g. by demographic group or decile). |
Section | Results – Work Incentives – narrative on labor supply or METR outcomes. | Technical documentation; Policy evaluation | Discuss changes in marginal/average tax rates and participation incentives. | Common in technical reports (e.g. “Work incentives” section). |
Section | Discussion/Implications – interpretation of findings and policy relevance. | Policy evaluation; Public summary | Highlight how results inform policy decisions, limitations. | Sometimes combined with conclusions; often in policy reports. |
Section | Conclusions – summary of findings and recommendations. | All (Policy; Technical; Public) | Recap main outcomes, policy implications, and suggest future work. | Always included at end. |
Section | Limitations / Caveats – discuss model uncertainties and omissions. | All (especially Technical; Policy) | Acknowledge data/model limitations, e.g. missing behaviors or groups. | Often brief; not always explicitly labeled. |
Section | References – bibliographic sources. | All | List citations of literature and data sources. | Standard in all formal reports. |
Section | List of Figures and Tables – index of figures/tables. | Technical documentation; Policy evaluation | Provide quick navigation to visual and tabular content. | Included if many figures/tables. |
Appendix / Annex | Data Sources and Processing – detailed info on input data (e.g. survey datasets). | Technical documentation | Document datasets used, imputation or projection methods. | E.g. list of SILC datasets; typically Annex. |
Appendix / Annex | Policy Parameters – full list of tax/benefit formulas, thresholds, rates. | Technical documentation | Provide complete policy rule specifications. | Sometimes as an annex (e.g. EUROMOD country reports). |
Appendix / Annex | Model Code / Syntax (Options) – list of model input options or code (e.g. TaxBEN syntax). | Technical documentation | Reference for advanced users detailing software commands or options. | See TaxBEN Annex C (list of options). |
Appendix / Annex | Supplementary Results – additional tables/figures not in main text. | Policy evaluation; Technical documentation | Include further breakdowns or alternative scenarios. | Optional; often for transparency and completeness. |
Appendix / Annex | Validation Checks – comparison of simulated outputs with official stats. | Technical documentation | Verify model accuracy (e.g. tax revenue, benefit totals). | Commonly tables comparing model vs admin data. |
Appendix / Annex | Glossary / Notation – definitions of terms and acronyms. | Public summary; Technical | Explain specialized terminology (e.g. METR, ARP). | Helpful for non-technical readers; may be in online docs (EUROMOD site) or report appendix. |
Bullet list | Key Findings (bullet points) – list of main results or messages. | Policy evaluation; Public summary | Quickly convey top-line results to readers. | Often in introduction or summary (e.g. IPPR report). |
Bullet list | Model Strengths / Features – list of capabilities or advantages. | Public summary; Technical | Emphasize model’s unique aspects (multi-country, open data). | Found in overviews of microsim models. |
Bullet list | Use Cases / Applications – examples of policy questions the model can address. | Public summary; Policy evaluation | Illustrate model flexibility (e.g. income distribution, work incentives). | E.g. EUROMOD “what can it do?” list. |
Figure | Model Structure Diagram – schematic of data flow and model modules. | Technical documentation | Illustrates components (tax calculator, microdata, interfaces). | Common in methodology sections (e.g. LOTTE model flow). |
Figure | Tax/Benefit Impact by Income Decile – bar or line chart of net effect on each decile. | Policy evaluation; Public summary | Show how reform affects households across income distribution. | Very common in reform analysis. |
Figure | Income Changes by Group – chart of changes in gross/disposable income by household type or decile. | Policy evaluation | Visualize distributional impact across demographic groups. | E.g. “changes in income by household type”. |
Figure | Tax/Benefit Changes by Group – chart of changes in taxes paid and benefits received by group. | Policy evaluation | Show who pays more or gets more under reform. | Used in distributional analysis. |
Figure | Poverty Rate Changes by Group – chart of reform effect on poverty by category (e.g. age). | Policy evaluation; Public summary | Highlight which groups exit/enter poverty due to policy. | E.g. “changes in poverty rate by household type”. |
Figure | Baseline vs Counterfactual Poverty (Lorenz/Poverty curves) – pre/post simulation poverty or income curves. | Policy evaluation | Illustrate how taxes/benefits lift below-poverty incomes. | E.g. “poverty risk & role of benefits”. |
Figure | Baseline vs Counterfactual Inequality (Gini) – income distribution or Gini comparison with/without taxes. | Policy evaluation | Show redistributive effect of tax-benefit system. | E.g. “Gini with/without policies”. |
Figure | METR Distribution – histogram of Marginal Effective Tax Rates by income or employment status. | Technical documentation; Policy evaluation | Analyze work incentives distribution under current policy. | Standard in labor supply sections. |
Figure | METR by Income Component – bar chart of average METR by types of income (wages, benefits). | Technical documentation | Compare work disincentives across different earnings components. | Common in reports on work incentives. |
Figure | Model Output Visualizations (maps, interactive charts) – simplified graphics for public briefs. | Public summary | Convey key results in an accessible form (e.g. infographic of winners/losers). | Used in one-page briefs or news releases (no specific citation). |
Table | Tax/Benefit Revenue Summary – simulation of total revenue/benefit spending by category. | Policy evaluation; Technical documentation | Report aggregate fiscal impact of policies. | E.g. “tax revenue by type”. |
Table | Policy Reform Costing – summary of revenue and spending differences (e.g. ΔTaxes, ΔBenefits). | Policy evaluation | Quantify budgetary effect of a reform (often by scenario). | Common in evaluation tables. |
Table | Distributional Statistics – summary of mean/median incomes, poverty rates, Gini, before/after reform. | Policy evaluation | Summarize key inequality/poverty measures to quantify effects. | Standard outcome table (e.g. ARP rates, Gini). |
Table | Distributional Impact by Decile/Quintile – decile/quintile breakdown of income or tax changes. | Policy evaluation | Detail how each income group is affected. | Often shown as differences or percentage changes. |
Table | Household/Group Definitions – description of categories (e.g. family types). | Policy evaluation | Clarify population subgroups used in analysis. | E.g. “Household type definitions”. |
Table | Baseline Validation – compare simulated outputs (tax receipts, benefits) to official data. | Technical documentation | Validate model accuracy against known aggregates. | E.g. LOTTE “simulated vs admin”; EUROMOD vs EU-SILC. |
Table | Behavioral Effects – break out direct vs behavioral impacts on revenue or labor supply. | Policy evaluation; Technical | Show how assumed elasticities alter results. | E.g. tax revenue with/without behavior. |
Table | Elasticity Estimates – labor supply or participation elasticities from model. | Technical documentation | Document key parameters used or estimated. | LOTTE example with participation/hours elasticities. |
Table | Self-Financing Ratios – revenue-change/income-change percentages for different policy changes. | Policy evaluation | Summarize fiscal return of reforms (static vs dynamic). | Used in policy design analysis. |
Table | Input Data Sources – list of surveys and administrative data used in simulation. | Technical documentation | Provide provenance of microdata (e.g. EU-SILC year versions). | Often in Annex; EUROMOD list of SILC datasets. |
Table | Model Adjustments Summary – details of non-take-up, compliance rates, regional modules. | Technical documentation | Document corrections applied to data/policies. | E.g. EUROMOD country adjustment notes. |
Table | Calibration Targets – comparison of model aggregates to targets (e.g. total tax revenue). | Technical documentation | Show fit of micro-sim to macro benchmarks. | (Common in US tax model docs; no source given here.) |
Box | Background Boxes – sidebars with definitions or context (e.g. “Tax wedge vs METR”). | Technical documentation; Public summary | Explain concepts or compare with other measures. | E.g. OECD boxes on METR indicators and RED index. |
Box | Policy Descriptions – concise notes on each tax/benefit rule. | Technical documentation; Public | Summarize specific policy rules. | E.g. OECD Box: “policy descriptions”. |
Sources: Examples drawn from tax-benefit microsimulation model documentation and evaluation reports (among others). The items above reflect common report elements across contexts (policy analysis, model technical reports, and public briefs).